---
title: "dialectic"
description: "Configuration-first multi-agent design debate. Agents with different roles (architect, security, performance, simplicity,...) run structured debate rounds and a judge decides when convergence is reached."
canonical: https://agentpluginsdirectory.com/plugins/dialectic
last-updated: 2026-11-13
---

# dialectic
Configuration-first multi-agent design debate. Agents with different roles (architect, security, performance, simplicity,...) run structured debate rounds and a judge decides when convergence is reached.
## Package we checked
plugin.json sits at the package root in slior/dialectic-agentic, which is the plugin directory the 1.0.0 spec describes. Its $schema is https://agent-plugins.org/schemas/1.0.0/plugin.schema.json. The manifest lists 2 skills (judge, orchestrate) and no MCP servers.
- Slug: dialectic
- Publisher: Lior Schejter
- Repository: https://github.com/slior/dialectic-agentic
- Manifest: plugin.json
- Version: 0.2.0
- License: MIT
- Category (editorial): agent-tooling
- Skills: 2 (judge, orchestrate)
- MCP servers: 0
- Stars: 4
- Repository created: 2026-02-20
- Repository last pushed: 2026-08-15
- Publisher type: User
- Listing: https://agentpluginsdirectory.com/plugins/dialectic
- Schema: https://agent-plugins.org/schemas/1.0.0/plugin.schema.json

## What dialectic does, in the publisher's words

A multi-agent design debate system implemented entirely as agent skill files, prompt templates, and a JSON config. No code required. Runs on any agentic platform that supports subagent dispatch (Cursor, Claude Code, etc.).

Give it a design problem. Multiple AI agents, each with a distinct expert role (architect, security, performance, simplicity), debate the problem through structured rounds of proposals, critiques, and refinements. A judge evaluates convergence after each round. The debate ends when the agents reach sufficient agreement or a round ceiling is hit. A judge synthesizes the final solution.

The entire system is driven by an agent following skill files. State lives in plain markdown and JSON files you can read at any time.

From the project README, punctuation lightly normalized. Full text: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/slior/dialectic-agentic/HEAD/README.md

## Skills

- judge: Evaluates convergence across agent refinements and, when the debate ends, writes the final synthesized solution. Operates in two modes: convergence_check (per-round verdict) and synthesis (final output). Use when the orchestrator needs a convergence verdict or a final synthesis document.
- orchestrate: Drives the full multi-agent design debate lifecycle: loads config, initializes the workspace, runs optional clarification, executes debate rounds (proposal, critique, refinement), dispatches the judge for convergence checks, and writes the final synthesis. Use when the user wants to start or run a…

Descriptions come from the frontmatter of each SKILL.md, punctuation lightly normalized.
